
Apple fans, re-hypnotize yourselves with the photo above and get ready for the wave of anti-Apple stories, because I can feel it coming. I've been in this business long enough to know how it works. They boost you up and hype your stuff and turn you into the reincarnation of Buddha himself; then they tear you down. It's not their fault. It's what they do. The big thing to know about the media is that they're not out there "covering stories." The way to think about the media is that it's basically the same as one of those TV soap operas that's been on the air for twenty or thirty years. The story just rolls on, curving and unfurling, no matter who the actors are and no matter who the writers are. The story itself is bigger than the actors or the writers. The filthy hacks at the Journal are basically no different than the aspiring novelists and screenwriters who take jobs writing for "General Hospital"; they've been hired on to the show for a few years and they're doing their best to keep it entertaining. People like me are the characters in the soap opera and what you realize early on if you're in my position is that you don't have much more control over the plot than do the actors who play roles in a TV soap opera. The trick is to figure out what part the filthy bastards are imposing on you and then to surf that wave and make the best of it.
It's also worth remembering that the writers don't have any control either. We tend to blame the reporters but really it's not their fault. They have to do as they're told. The story has certain demands. Heroes achieve things and win; then they fuck up and fall; then they dust themselves off and overcome obstacles and climb back into the ring, blah blah blah. The writers just make up the details to keep it colorful.
Anyway, the backlash is coming. Sooner rather than later some a-hole who thinks he's really smart is going to write the "contrarian" piece saying Apple is crap. Of course this point of view is not really contrarian at all; in fact it's inevitable, and it's a requirement of the overarching narrative that we're all part of. But whatever. He'll think he's a big bad ass who's figured something out before everyone else and dares to say it out loud. You know why this is? Because most of the poor dimwits who work in the media are so clueless that they don't realize they're part of a big overarching ongoing story. They're like the pod people in "The Matrix," churning away at their computers, totally unaware of the reality in which they're living. They don't realize that they're just harnessed to the soap opera that's writing itself with or without them; most of them really think they're "breaking" stories and shaping the news. Poor saps. The fact is that all the journalists I've ever met boasted a combination of incredible naivete and limited intelligence with an exaggerated sense of self-importance and a wrongheaded belief that they are a great deal smarter than the people they interview. Without those things you just couldn't do their job.
In our case right now the backlash started with Dvorak, that grumpy old liver-spotted bastard, saying maybe it's time to start shorting Apple stock. More recently we've seen the general grumbling about the WWDC keynote and how it lacked sparkle. The great thing about the press and their ongoing narrative is that this makes them utterly friggin predictable. Steve Dowling and I sat around yesterday in a PR strategy session and mapped out exactly what the papers will do. Here are some data points:
* The stock is too high, has gone up too fast, is due for a "correction."
* We've hyped the iPhone so much that it can never live up to the expectations we've created and therefore is bound to be a disappointment. The touch screen is going to drive people nuts.
* The iPod is great but at this point we can't sell any more than we already do, so there's no way to go but down.
* Apple TV is a flop.
* Leopard is late, a sign we're struggling in the labs.
* Leopard is a letdown. The first glimpse of it got tepid reviews in general and some, like Mary Jo Creepy, actually claimed we're stealing from Vista.
* The current iMacs and Mac Mini have gone nearly 300 days without a refresh; we've lost our way.
* Technology is changing again and iTunes-to-iPod model isn't the way of the future; it's going to be streaming technology and we don't play a role there.
* Movie companies aren't getting on board with iTunes.
* Vista got bashed for being such a hardware hog but Leopard is going to be just as power hungry, needing at least 2 gigs of RAM to run decently.
The question is, how do we respond? Do we fight it? We think not. It would be like fighting a tsunami. Better off to get to high ground and ride out the storm. I call it the Obi-Wan Kenobi defense. I put on my brown robe, turn off my light saber, and just let the bad guys attack me. It's a necessary part of the story. The story needs me to fail now, to suffer, so that then I can come back in even greater glory. It's like Jesus -- no crucifixion, no resurrection. Media whores, listen to me: If you strike me down, I shall become more powerful than you could possibly imagine.
Saturday, June 16, 2007
Apple faithful, we must prepare together for the media backlash
Posted by
Steve
at
4:00 AM
Labels: Filthy hacks, Media whores
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


49 comments:
Hmfff. Youngling. Much to learn you have.
time to bring out the special edition brown ipod to keep all those non-believers happy
...the sound of inevitability
But Steve, couldn't you just pump up the RDF on the media? Oh that's right, you damaged it by being around Bill. How long does an RDF take to repair itself?
hahaha
what a post
i wonder how often realsteve reads this
Hey Steve,
you'll be fine. I just watched your keynote from Paris 2000 where you showed the aqua interface, you remember. You showed just no-brainers like "look i can drag things in the dock etc." and the people loved it. Why? Because you were aggressive. You were really fighting on stage with a very powerful voice. You should try that again. With that you can show things like Spaces for ours and you'll get your standing ovations.
Those people are just spoiled anyway. I tell you - Apple Expo Paris - Keynote 2000!
*Cheers!* (loves Star Wars quote). Wow... some of that can be defended. But some of that is pure... well you get the point. I mean Apple TV isn't even a flop. SJ said it was just a Hobby compared to the others. And if Apple is not expecting that much out of it, how can it be a flop?
Regarding your Buddha metaphor, let's consider the 9 characteristics of a buddha:
1. a worthy one
2. perfectly self-enlightened
3. stays in perfect knowledge
4. well gone
5. unsurpassed knower of the world
6. unsurpassed leader of persons to be tamed
7. teacher of the gods and humans
8. the Enlightened One
9. the Blessed One or fortunate one.
Fuck it, I got a your name at the top and tick beside each one of those bad boys.
Steve - you are so damned right about the media and the backlash that is coming... next stop on the train, of course, will be the iPhone launch. We will get the "lines out the door... how can you possibly get one of these things" coverage on the 29th and 30th, then within a couple of days the media will be full of stories knocking the thing down. The screen scratches when I forcefully dig my car keys into it, the battery life sucks and it doesn't feed my cat like the nice man in the AT&T store told me it would. The thing will go from being the greatest advance in the history of communications one day to a shameful flop within 48 hours. But we must stay strong... hold firm... Stay hungry, because they are most definitely foolish.
Godspeed, Steve.
Steve - you are so damned right about the media and the backlash that is coming... next stop on the train, of course, will be the iPhone launch. We will get the "lines out the door... how can you possibly get one of these things" coverage on the 29th and 30th, then within a couple of days the media will be full of stories knocking the thing down. The screen scratches when I forcefully dig my car keys into it, the battery life sucks and it doesn't feed my cat like the nice man in the AT&T store told me it would. The thing will go from being the greatest advance in the history of communications one day to a shameful flop within 48 hours. But we must stay strong... hold firm... Stay hungry, because they are most definitely foolish.
Godspeed, Steve.
Isn't that exactly what John C. Dvorak (yes, the dude from that ugly-looking www.dvorak.org/blog) has already been doing for months and years with no effect whatsoever?!
Chin up, old chap. I predict the anti-Google narrative will soon be so overwhelming that no-one will bother to write anti-Apple pieces. You should fear obscurity more than opprobrium.
HI Steve, really enjoyed the post, that's a great writing, its really quite true about the media, but I'm sure that at day's end Apple shall prevail the dark forces of the empire.
Think Different
Absolutely spot on. What's the alternative - an expectation that at Macworld and WWDC every year, Apple will pull a revolutionary product out of the secret labs.
Only problem is that looking around, there's not exactly anyone else waiting in the wings. Sony lost it's touch a few years back and has yet to rediscover it's purpose (hell, it's content and hardware wings are fighting each other). MS? Lot of smart people, but picking battles on too many fronts to have a focus. Only weird people who actually HATE Apple are MS fans. 'I don't like Apple, the people who like Macs also like things like razor blades and personal hygeine and put too much value on apperance - why do they always get hotter looking women?'
That is probably one of the best indictments of the current state of "the press" that I've read.
I think our Founders would be shaking their heads in shame at a press that they fought so hard to protect, which has become (as Rather put it) "Dumbed down and tarted up".
They would witness your perspective on the news cycle becoming a story arc with equal dread.
(Forgive me for violating Willful Suspension of Disbelief) FSJ: you need keep that post and make sure it gets properly attributed to you once your done with this gig.
Fake Steve knows:
1. the media at a fairly detailed level, as shown in previous coverage of the Journal among others
2. Carl Jung / Joe Campbell archetypal myths and how to spot their patterns at large
3. that Buddha isn't due a reincarnation as that's for losers, and he ain't no living Bodhisattva either … therefore completing the joke
This leads me to believe that our favourite blogger has:
1. either been a journalist or worked with them closely enough to recognise their toxic smell, and other bodily habits
2. has been reading the right texts for one who wishes to emulate a certain class of Californian countercultural patriarchs
3. may well have been a little too into the above for himself at one point
Anyway, as wrong as my feeble attempts at insight are in themselves, this post is spot on. I wouldn't be surprised at all if Apple command have as good an idea of the onslaught ahead as you do. It's been done a thousand times, with a thousand left to remain.
fuck it. put on your pirate hat and weather the storm. won't be the first time, eh, jobso?
2 GIGS OF RAM?!?!?!?! lol
I'd cry. Too funny. And a little bit scary...
Like when you're eating something, and you can't recognize from what animal it came.
FSJ would look great with Jesus hair.
I thought FSJ was supposed to be satire. What's with all this simple truth stuff?
Oh, and "Fake John Dvorak" is an oxymoron.
The Buddha, Obi Wan Kenobi, and Jesus Christ rolled into one. Is even Steve Jobs megalomaniac enough to believe he's that? And never mind the three-way internal contradictions there, which must be pretty mind-boggling.
You only left out Socrates. OTOH, you did, apparently, once say, “I would trade all of my technology for an afternoon with Socrates.”
Actually, that surprised me, because I didn't know you followed soccer. He's a top goalscorer for Brazil, isn't he?
Legends: Socrates
That.
Was awesome.
Well Fake One,
No doubt some in the media WILL tear apart the iPhone. BUT, the people will love it. As long as you took care of the "scratch" issue that plagued the Nano and iPod, because my 5G is scratched to hell, but the razor phone I carry in a pocket WITH my keys is unscathed.
Certainly some will play devils advocate, but as long as the phone delivers, it won't matter much. The important thing is the phone is WRITTEN about. Press Good.
I know I want one but my contract is not up until next year, so it will have to wait.
I'm gonna take the "red pill" and I hope the truth is as good as I imagined for this device.
>> Mary Jo Creepy, actually claimed we're stealing from Vista.
Yeah, but was a poorly researched article.
More generally,
Apple will always have its detractors like Dvorak but the products will speak for themselves. Why do people depend on reviewers to tell them how something is? People have their own brains and they are not(or should not be) afraid to use them.
Why don't you steal some more of my ideas, Steve?
Why don't you steal some more of my ideas, Steve?
O wise Fake Steve, thou hast plumbed the depths of this very shallow media world.
They have tapped into The Story. First it's "Oh, look at that cute Lindsay Lohan. Just out of pigtails and now she's going out with boys!" Then it's "She-wolf of the Psychotic Hollywood Cult."
Facts be damned. They worship Baal.
Wooh.
Leopard's gonna need 2 gigs to run right?
The last Apple Dark Age was the (keeping with the Star Wars motif) attack of the clones. You got us out of that in a jiffy. That was when Apple lost sight of itself a a dual hardware/software company, and we have to be careful not to go too far in either direction. Loose the hardware and we're MS; focus on it exclusively and we become IBM--or as I like to say, iBM.
I have faith in you and your Allen Kay quote. Hopefully the RDF will be recharged by the 29th, or at least by October. (And don't leave us with nothing between then!)
Let Apple TV handle TV-signals! Show and record... or ....bundle the shitty Apple Tv with PS3 :)
When you release iPhone (after summer) in Europe we demand a 5 mega pixel camera, 3G and an GPS blue tooth dongle.
Give us a new iPod without the phone stuff!
Give us iLife07, iWork07 and a pro iWeb!
and a ultra portable that weighs 1 KG!!
Make iCal sync with Google calender!
Just do it now!
Pleeeeeeeeeeeeease!!!!
Brilliant!
For more on the master narrative in journalism, see here in PressThink.
It would be like fighting a tsunami. Better off to get to high ground and ride out the storm.
Don't know about you, Steve, but in Caledonia, when the the tsunami is coming, we head to the high ground.
Lots of High Ground in Caledonia,
->AMD FanBoi
{sniff!} fsj, be you fakey-steve-o or real, that has to be one of the most awe-inspiring and absolutely true things i've ever read on the web or any where else. it was so simple yet earth-shatteringly true, i had to ask myself: sheezus, is he keeping his "fake" status for the simple fact that if anyone knew who he really was, the forces that be would have sent an agent to put a bullet right in his brain pan to keep truth like this from being disseminated long ago?
you are right, fsj. a cyclical, sad melodrama, re-played over and over in suffering for those who are to motivated by their own ravenous hunger and desire and cannot bring themselves to get off the gerbil-cage wheel. the question is, fsj — how do you keep your sanity through all this? what kind of mind-bending, altering, rdf, zen, jedi powers must you truly have to be able to withstand the onslaughts again and again, and not have the flesh repeatedly ripped from you limbs by the jackals?
it's cold out there, man. and dark. i can hear their howls at the edge of the dusk. how can we possibly survive the onslaught, fsj? how? i tremble with the fear, yet the cold sweat dripping down my temple and back have never made me feel more alive. the fear has gripped me, fsj. tell me — how can we withstand it all, over and over again? i can feel them closing in... how can we go on? how can we survive? lead us, oh fearless electronic buddha. lead us... {collapses, whimpering in a corner before a flickering candle-light goes out completely, and sounds of ravenous howls in the distance close in...}
Apple Developer Connection members that have paid for Developer support from Apple that did not attend WWDC have not seen this release of Leopard seeded to the ADC download website. It's a shame that Wired Magazine get's to see this release of Leopard before people that pay for this privilege get to see it. Apple needs to take action to correct this issue. ASAP.
One would suspect that ADC members would have had access to this release just shortly after it's announcement and being handed out at WWDC, but this is not the case!!! What a shame. Boo hiss!
fsj, you're charitably kind in describing the media as clueless dimwits. in truth, the media are hopeless, clueless dimwits.
Nice post Steve. I agree with you on a number of levels -- especially the overarching storyline aspect. There are times when I wonder why "the powers that be" ask me to cover a story that has been covered already and come up with a "new angle." There's only one way you can spin a start-up, or a product launch, or a software gaffe.
But as a "new media" journalist -- one who loves the "I'm a Mac" commercials, and rocks out to her iPod, and is typing on her MacBook Pro -- I take offense to your description of hacks as having:
"a combination of incredible naivete and limited intelligence with an exaggerated sense of self-importance and a wrongheaded belief that they are a great deal smarter than the people they interview"
I for one, know technologists, analysts, chefs, parents, teachers ... the list goes on and on ... who are much smarter than me. And I'm delighted at the opportunity to interview them and share their light with the world.
you can hear the dew fall.
only your eyes are unclosed.
Hey, AMD fanboi:
Don't know about you, Steve, but in Caledonia, when the the tsunami is coming, we head to the high ground.
FSJ said "Better off to get to high ground," not "Better to get off high ground."
A big-endian/little-endian bug, perhaps?
Hey, The Economist?
Fake Steve:
I know there are troubled times ahead for you. I could sense that in your interview with Bill Gates at the D conference. You mentioned that people sometimes forget how good the times have been for tech. The apocalypse is near. Time to cash out of your stock options to better your karma. Let not the dark storm clouds of the media dampen your spirit. You are a whole person. You are the leader, O fake Steve. Be at peace with yourself o' wise one.
FSJ,
Excellent work.
ps
sorry for the double post
Come on, FSJ, just lash back.
Here is some badly researched cannon fodder for you:
here
Real Steve Jobs gets a hard-on when he reads this stuff. I'm positive he wishes he could say this kind of thing in public.
I wouldn't say he's envious, what with being worth Billions and all. But I'll bet he wouldn't mind the chance to vent his spleen now and then.
*** 5 minutes with hypnopic***
Bye now. Gotta see about completing some albums, upgrading to non-DRM and maybe pick up some podcasts. And maybe some music videos, though it would really kick ass if I could watch those on an iPod that was all screen.
Fake John Dvorak is a tautology, not an oxymoron
You can't win, Darth. If you strike me down, I shall become more powerful than you could possibly imagine.
I love you Steve and I love you more FakeSteve...can't wait to get my iphone!
Ze Frank
http://cache.gizmodo.com/gadgets/images/iProduct.gif
Look. Read. Believe. BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!! BILL GATES OWNS YOU!
Post a Comment